Like many Americans, I watched the Vice Presidential debates last night. And, again - like many Americans - was expecting a train-wreck. I didn’t get one, but that doesn’t mean I’ve changed my mind on Sarah Palin. It means she was extremely well rehearsed, decently coached, and naturally comes across as warm, genial, and charming.
The after-debate analysis from Pat Buchanan and Rachel Maddow was great. Pat Buchanan described Biden as boring, while Palin was constrastingly exciting. Maddow then quipped that America’s choice has become “Boring and right, or Exciting and wrong.” I was hoping to hear about more of the instant polling like CNN did during the last Presidential debate, but it was noticeably absent.
So, this debate was full of a whole lot of nothing, and that’s fine. The debate was Palin’s to win or lose. All Biden had to do was show up and be courteous. Give nothing to the wingnuts to latch onto and claim Joe was being unkind or unctuous. He did a great job, with a few mistakes - sure.
As a side note, any time I hear so-and-so voted for a bill, or raised taxes, I always take that info with a giant grain of salt. On the one hand, Biden claimed that McCain voted to raise taxes in the same way that Obama did (though, that analysis is, itself, incorrect) when in truth, McCain voted for an amendment to that bill, but ultimately voted the bill itself down. Palin claimed that Obama voted to raise taxes on families making just $42k a year. Actually, the vote was to repeal the Bush tax-cuts,which had individual $42k earners paying more. Voting for a removal of a tax-cut isn’t the same as voting for a tax increase.
Both candidates made those kind of errors (or should we call them exaggerations?), and even each-other out, in my opinion. Style points to Palin for being warm and cheerful, but big minus points for not answering the questions that Gwen Ifill asked. Biden looked steady and showed his absolute command of the issues, showing nuance of thought and analysis.
If I weighed those points evenly, I’d call it a tie, but I don’t think style should count as much as intelligence, so I’d give the debate to Biden. Don’t get me wrong - Palin did well, but she’s just not presidential. After this election, I’d say she has a great career ahead of her as a Fox news pundit.